Skip to content
HomeMortgageOnline
Guide

FHA vs Conventional Loans: How to Compare Total Cost

Two small house models, a calculator, and a pencil on a kitchen table

FHA and conventional loans differ on down payment, credit-score floors, and how long mortgage insurance lasts. These are program rules.

Published: 2026-11-16

Key takeaways

  • An FHA purchase can go to 96.5 percent of Adjusted Value if the borrower invests at least 3.5 percent.
  • FHA scores of 580 and above can use maximum financing. Scores from 500 to 579 cap loan-to-value at 90 percent. Under 500 is not eligible for case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2027.
  • Fannie Mae's manual minimum is 620 on a fixed-rate loan and 640 on an ARM. Desktop Underwriter publishes no minimum score.
  • Above 95 percent loan-to-value, annual FHA MIP on a term over 15 years, with a base loan amount at or under $726,200, is 55 basis points for the mortgage term. Many PMI policies can end at 78 percent of original value.
  • A labeled $200,000 example shows the loan amounts only. It does not say which loan costs less.

Published: 2026-11-16

Why the monthly insurance line is only part of the cost

A lower monthly insurance charge is not always the lower cost over the years you keep the loan. FHA mortgage insurance (MIP) can last the mortgage term. Conventional private mortgage insurance (PMI) can end under CFPB cancellation rules. The figures below are program rules from HUD, the CFPB, and Fannie Mae. They are not an approval and not an interest rate. The FHA loan guide and the loan types guide map the programs.

What cash does each purchase program require?

On an FHA purchase, Handbook 4000.1 says Adjusted Value is the lesser of price minus inducements, or property value. Maximum loan-to-value is 96.5 percent of Adjusted Value, and the minimum investment is at least 3.5 percent of Adjusted Value. HUD's consumer page says the down payment can be as low as 3.5 percent of the price on 1 to 4 unit properties.

Fannie Mae B2-1.3-01 (November 5, 2025) adds rules when purchase loan-to-value exceeds 95 percent. The band is 95.01 to 97 percent. Combined loan-to-value can reach 105 percent only with a Community Seconds lien. The loan must be fixed-rate, up to 30 years, and it cannot be high-balance or an ARM. It must be a one-unit principal residence. Manufactured housing must be MH Advantage. Borrowers occupy unless a Community Seconds lien is present. At least one borrower must be a first-time homebuyer on Form 1003, tied to a No answer on owning a property in the last three years. Desktop Underwriter is required. HomeReady is outside these rows. Education rules are in B2-2-06.

HomeReady, B5-6-02 (November 5, 2025), allows 97 percent loan-to-value in Desktop Underwriter and 95 percent on a manual file for a one-unit principal residence. Above 80 percent loan-to-value, that one-unit purchase does not require a minimum from the borrower's own funds. Two to four units above 80 percent loan-to-value require a 3 percent own-funds contribution unless there is a grant. That 3 percent line is not a universal conventional down payment.

Which credit-score floors are published?

At an FHA score of 580 or above, maximum financing is allowed. From 500 to 579, loan-to-value is capped at 90 percent. Non-traditional or insufficient credit can use maximum financing on a manual file. Mortgagee Letter 2026-11 (October 8, 2026) says a score under 500 is not eligible for FHA insurance, for case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2027. The letter's 97.75 percent figure is a refinance maximum, not the 96.5 percent purchase cap.

Fannie Mae B3-5.1-01 (November 4, 2026) requires 620 for a manual fixed-rate loan and 640 for a manual ARM. Desktop Underwriter loan casefiles have no minimum credit score, and lenders still request scores. Government loans Fannie Mae delivers need a representative score of at least 620. That is a delivery rule, not the FHA floor.

How long do MIP and PMI last?

Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 covers most forward FHA loans endorsed on or after March 20, 2023. Upfront MIP is 175 basis points (1.75 percent) of the base loan amount. For a term over 15 years and a base loan amount at or under $726,200, annual MIP is 50 basis points for 11 years at or below 90 percent loan-to-value, 50 basis points for the mortgage term from above 90 through 95 percent, and 55 basis points for the mortgage term above 95 percent. The letter writes 175 basis points as 1.75 percent, so 55 basis points is 0.55 percent. Duration follows original loan-to-value. The handbook measures that ratio on the base loan before financed upfront MIP, and the total mortgage may include that premium.

The CFPB says PMI may be required under a 20 percent down payment. It protects the lender, and foreclosure is still possible. On many single-family principal residences closed on or after July 29, 1999, a written request can cancel PMI at 80 percent of original value when the history is good, the loan is current, there is no junior lien, and value has not declined. PMI also ends at 78 percent if you are current, and the month after the midpoint, which is 15 years on a 30-year loan. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac cannot be less favorable. FHA and VA rules differ. Use the PMI and MIP comparison and the PMI calculator. This page does not pick a winner or quote a rate.

What does the FHA appraisal add?

An FHA appraisal checks value and HUD acceptability. The home must be safe, sound, and secure. If it does not comply, the appraiser notes repairs and an estimated cost to cure. If defects cannot be fixed, the mortgagee must reject the property. A conventional appraisal follows the investor selling guide.

How the years you keep the loan change the bill

On that over-95 percent row, annual MIP lasts the mortgage term, and a later paydown does not shorten it. PMI can end at the 80 percent and 78 percent points when the conditions are met. The years you keep the loan decide how much of each schedule you actually pay.

A labeled illustration on a $200,000 price

Assume a $200,000 price, no inducements, and a value at least that high, so Adjusted Value is $200,000. A lower appraisal lowers it. Closing costs and interest are left out.

Maximum FHA purchase financing is 96.5 percent, or $193,000. The 3.5 percent investment is $7,000. Upfront MIP of 1.75 percent is $3,377.50, and financing it produces $196,377.50. That sum is not a monthly payment. At 96.5 percent loan-to-value the annual MIP row is 55 basis points for the mortgage term. A score from 500 to 579 caps the loan at 90 percent, or $180,000, a $20,000 gap that is 10 percent of this price and not a full cash-to-close figure.

A Fannie Mae purchase at 97 percent loan-to-value is $194,000, a $6,000 or 3 percent gap. It sits in the 95.01 to 97 percent band unless it is HomeReady, and PMI may be required because the down payment is under 20 percent. No PMI dollar is assigned, and neither file is called the cheaper one.

This article is educational and is not a loan offer or financial advice.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is a lower FHA monthly charge always the lower total cost?

No. Annual MIP on a high loan-to-value FHA loan can last the mortgage term. PMI on many loans can be requested at 80 percent of original value and can end at 78 percent. The years you keep the loan change the total. This page does not say which loan costs less.

What down payment does an FHA purchase require?

At least 3.5 percent of Adjusted Value, with a maximum purchase loan-to-value of 96.5 percent. HUD's consumer page says the down payment can be as low as 3.5 percent of the purchase price on 1 to 4 unit properties. That is a program rule, not an approval.

What credit score does Fannie Mae publish?

Manual files need 620 on a fixed-rate loan and 640 on an ARM. Desktop Underwriter loan casefiles have no published minimum score. FHA uses the 580 and 500 to 579 bands, plus the under-500 rule in Mortgagee Letter 2026-11.

Does a later paydown cancel FHA annual MIP?

Not on the row for loan-to-value above 95 percent, a term longer than 15 years, and a base loan amount at or under $726,200. That annual MIP is 55 basis points for the mortgage term.

What else does an FHA appraisal check?

The home must be safe, sound, and secure. The appraiser notes repairs and a cost to cure. If defects cannot be fixed, the mortgagee must reject the property. A conventional appraisal follows the investor selling guide.